Your monthly electricity bill is $100. Winter arrives and it goes up 20%. In spring it falls 20%. Back to $100, right? No. It lands at $96. The two 20%s are not the same size of money, and that catches people out with bills, prices, pay rises, and any “up then down” headline.
(Every number here is invented to show the method. The same sums work for any amount.)
Step 1: the rise
20% of $100 is $20. So the bill becomes $100 + $20 = $120.
A quicker route is a multiplier: a rise of 20% means “times 1.20”, so 100 × 1.20 = 120.
Step 2: the fall
Now the bill falls 20%. But 20% of what? Of the new bill, $120, not of the original $100.
20% of $120 = $24, so the bill becomes $120 − $24 = $96.
As a multiplier, “down 20%” means “times 0.80”, so 120 × 0.80 = 96.
Step 3: the overall change
Both steps together: 1.20 × 0.80 = 0.96. The bill finishes at 96% of where it began, which is 4% lower, or $4 short.
The order does not change this: 0.80 × 1.20 is also 0.96. What matters is that each percentage is measured from a different starting amount. The 20% rise is taken from $100 and the 20% fall from $120, so the fall is the bigger sum of money.
A smaller version of the same effect: a 10% pay cut followed by a 10% raise gives 0.90 × 1.10 = 0.99, so you finish 1% below where you began. The smaller the percentages, the smaller the gap, but it is never zero.
A handy way to keep the bases straight: ask “20% of what?” every time, and write the amount down. For quick mental work, 20% is one fifth, so 20% of $100 is $100 ÷ 5 = $20, and 20% of $120 is $120 ÷ 5 = $24.
What fall would actually undo a 20% rise?
To get back from $120 to $100, you need to remove $20. As a share of $120, that is 20 ÷ 120 = 1/6, or about 16.7%.
The general rule: if something goes up by a fraction, the fall that undoes it is smaller than that fraction. For a 20% rise it is 1 − 1/1.2 = 16.7%. The reverse also holds: a 20% fall needs a 25% rise to undo it (80 × 1.25 = 100), which is bigger than 20%.
Putting it to work on your own bills
Say a phone plan of $40 a month goes up 15%, and a rival offers a 15% discount on the new price. It does not bring you back to $40. Check it: 40 × 1.15 = $46.00, and 46 × 0.85 = $39.10, so you do end up a little under $40, because 0.85 × 1.15 = 0.9775. The discount, taken from the bigger number, removes more than the increase added.
Now try the reverse order. A 15% discount first gives 40 × 0.85 = $34.00, and a 15% rise on that gives 34 × 1.15 = $39.10. Same total, since multiplying works in any order. What changes is the story you are told, so look at the final price, not the percentages.
Every figure here is rounded to the nearest cent.
The same trap in shops
Two sales stacked on top of each other work the same way. Take 20% off a $100 item and it is $80. Take another 20% off that and it is 80 × 0.8 = $64, so $16 off the second time, not $20. The total saving is 36%, not 40% (which would have given $60).
So whenever you see two percentages chained, do not add them. Multiply the multipliers.
Quick checks you can do in your head
- Up then down by the same percentage always ends below the start. For 20%, the loss is 4% (0.2 × 0.2 = 0.04). For 10% it is 1%, and for 50% it is 25%: $100 up 50% is $150, and down 50% is $75.
- Down then up by the same percentage also ends below the start, for the same reason.
- The product shortcut: the overall change is the product of the multipliers, so if the answer should be 1.00 and it is not, the bases differ.
When a headline says “prices fell 20% after rising 20%”, you now know the price did not return, and you can work out where it stands.
Try it with your own numbers
The free Stacked Percentages calculator lets you chain rises, falls, discounts and amounts in any order. It shows the value after each step, the overall multiplier and the real overall change. It comes from Fractions, Decimals and Percentages Didn’t Have to Be This Hard, where chapters 13 and 14 cover percent change and stacked discounts.
Rule of thumb: percentages only cancel when they are measured from the same amount. Turn each one into a multiplier (up 20% is ×1.2, down 20% is ×0.8), multiply them, and read the answer off.
This is arithmetic for checking prices and bills, not financial advice.