Your team needs a new machine: a label printer for a small shop, a better coffee grinder for a cafe, a heavier stapler for a print room. The details do not matter. What matters is that there are two options, one cheap and one dear, and everybody has a different opinion about which is “better value.”
Here is a clean way to settle it with three numbers: payback, return, and the total at the end. They can disagree, and it is worth knowing why.
The two options
Both are examples with made-up money.
- Machine A: costs $1,200 and saves $50 a week (time, materials, mistakes).
- Machine B: costs $3,000 and saves $90 a week.
We will look at three years, which is 156 weeks, at 52 weeks a year.
Step 1: payback period
Payback answers: “how long until it has earned back what I paid?” Divide the cost by the weekly saving.
- A: 1,200 ÷ 50 = 24 weeks
- B: 3,000 ÷ 90 = 33.3, so about 33 weeks (round up to 34 if you count whole weeks)
A pays itself back nine or ten weeks earlier. If cash is tight, or if you are not sure the savings will last, that is a real advantage.
Step 2: total gain over three years
Savings over 156 weeks, minus what you paid:
- A: 50 × 156 = 7,800, minus 1,200 = $6,600
- B: 90 × 156 = 14,040, minus 3,000 = $11,040
By the end, B has earned $4,440 more than A (11,040 − 6,600). The slower payback hides a bigger machine.
Step 3: return on investment
ROI is the gain divided by the cost, as a percentage.
- A: 6,600 ÷ 1,200 = 5.5, so 550%
- B: 11,040 ÷ 3,000 = 3.68, so 368%
Now A looks best again. Each dollar spent on A returned more dollars than each dollar spent on B. So we have three measures and two winners: A wins on payback and ROI, B wins on the total.
Step 4: find the crossover
Where do the two lines meet? Set the net gains equal: 50 × w − 1,200 = 90 × w − 3,000. Move things across: 1,800 = 40 × w, so w = 45 weeks. At week 45 both machines have netted 50 × 45 − 1,200 = $1,050.
Before week 45, A is ahead. After week 45, B is ahead, and the gap grows by $40 every week. That crossover is the most useful number for the decision, because it turns the argument into a question you can answer: will we still be using this machine, and saving this much, in 45 weeks?
Step 5: ask what could be wrong
These numbers assume the weekly saving is steady and the machine lasts three years. Test the weak spots:
- If the machine would be replaced after 40 weeks, A is the better buy ($800 net, against $600 for B).
- If B’s real saving were $70 instead of $90, the break-even with A would move out to 1,800 ÷ 20 = 90 weeks.
- If you could not afford $3,000 without borrowing, add the cost of borrowing to B before you compare.
None of these makes one answer right for everyone. They show which assumption the choice depends on, so you can check that one first.
Putting it in words
If someone asks you in a meeting, you can say it in two sentences. “Machine A pays itself back in 24 weeks, and B in about 33. B only pulls ahead after week 45, and by the end of three years it has netted about $4,400 more.” Notice that the second sentence tells your boss exactly what they need to be sure of, and the first tells them how much risk they carry while they wait.
Rule of thumb
Payback = cost ÷ saving per period. Total gain = savings × time − cost. Find the week the two lines cross. Cheap-and-quick wins on payback and percent return, while dear-but-bigger often wins on the total, as long as it keeps working past the crossover.
Try it with your own numbers
The free ROI & Payback calculator gives return, payback period and expected value for one option or two side by side. It belongs to The Work Math Workout, whose book page says it covers markup and margin, percentage change, break-even, pay, charts, statistics and comparing options on return, payback and what you give up by choosing one.
Every figure here is made up. This is arithmetic for planning, not financial or accounting advice.