The recipe says 8 × 8 and you own a 9 × 13. Do you double it, scale it a little, or bake it as it is? The answer is in the area of the pan, and it takes one division. Get it wrong and the cake is a thin dry sheet or a raw middle.
Rule: compare areas
scale factor = your pan’s area ÷ the recipe’s pan area
- An 8 × 8 square: 8 × 8 = 64 sq in
- A 9 × 13 rectangle: 9 × 13 = 117 sq in
- A 9-inch round: 3.14 × 4.5 × 4.5 = 63.6 sq in
- An 8-inch round: 3.14 × 4 × 4 = 50.3 sq in
An 8 × 8 recipe in a 9 × 13 needs 117 ÷ 64 = 1.83 times the recipe. Not double.
Round against square
A 9-inch round at 63.6 sq in is almost exactly an 8 × 8 at 64, so you can swap those with no change. An 8-inch round is 50.3 and a 9-inch is 63.6, which is 27% more batter. Judging by the width alone, 8 against 9 looks like a small step, but the area, which is what holds the batter, grows faster.
Depth sets the baking time
Suppose you have 6 cups of batter. A US cup is 14.44 cubic inches (a gallon is 231 cubic inches, a cup a sixteenth of that), so 6 cups is 86.64 cubic inches.
- In the 8 × 8: 86.64 ÷ 64 = 1.35 in deep
- In the 9 × 13: 86.64 ÷ 117 = 0.74 in deep
Deeper batter takes longer to bake through, and thinner bakes faster, so in the 9 × 13 check early. A doubled 8 × 8 recipe is 128 sq in of batter’s worth of pan, and the 9 × 13 holds 117, so it sits 128 ÷ 117 = 1.09 times as deep, about 9% deeper than the recipe intends: bake a little longer.
Honest limits
This scales the amounts and warns you about depth, but it does not give a new baking time or oven temperature. Start checking at about three quarters of the time, and trust a skewer or the recipe’s own signs, not the clock.
Try your own pans
The free Pan Size Swap calculator takes the recipe’s pan, your pan and the batter, and gives the scale factor and the depth. Amounts can be typed as 3/4 or 1 1/2. It comes from Kitchen Numbers Didn’t Have to Be This Hard, which shows how to scale any recipe, convert cups and grams, swap pans and ingredients and time a meal, with plant-based examples. It is available on Kindle.
Worked examples from the book. Ovens vary; trust your own checks.